Email subject line tester for cold emails and newsletters
Type a subject line and its preview text, pick cold email or newsletter, and this tester scores the line out of 100 with every rule shown. It checks length and the mobile cut-off, ALL CAPS, !!! and $$$, hype words, emoji, merge tags and fake "Re:" prefixes. Everything runs in your browser.
How the score works
How does this email subject line tester score a line?
Every line starts at 100. The tester takes points off for patterns that tend to hurt: lines too long for a phone, ALL CAPS words, stacked !!! or $$$, hype words, broken merge tags, fake "Re:" prefixes and a missing or repeated preview text. Cold emails get stricter rules.
| Check | Cold or sales email | Newsletter |
|---|---|---|
| Word count | 2–6 words: 0. 1 word or 7–9: −5. 10+: −15 | Up to 12 words: 0. More: −5 |
| Length (with sample values) | Over 60 characters: −10 | Over 70: −10. Over 90: −20 |
Fake Re: or Fwd: | −25 | −25 |
| ALL CAPS word (4+ letters, not a known acronym) | −10, whole line in caps −20 | Same |
| Exclamation marks | Any: −5. Two or more in a row: −10 | Two or more in a row: −10 |
| Currency signs | Any $: −5. $$: −10 | $$: −10 |
| Hype or caution words (free, guaranteed, act now…) | −5 each, up to −15 | Same |
| Emoji | Any: −10 | More than 2: −5 |
| Broken merge tag | −15 | −15 |
| No personalisation | −5 | 0 |
| Preview text | Same as subject −5, placeholder text −10 | Missing −5, same as subject −5, placeholder −10 |
These weights are our judgement from writing and reviewing B2B campaigns, not measured effects. Use the score to catch problems, then A/B test the lines that pass.
Two different jobs
Cold email vs newsletter subject lines: what changes?
A cold email subject should read like a colleague wrote it: short, lowercase-friendly, specific to the person, no emoji and no sales words. A newsletter subject can carry more: a topic, a number, the issue's main idea, even one emoji, because the reader already knows the sender and signed up to hear from you.
| Cold or sales email | Newsletter | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal of the line | Get a stranger to open one email from a person | Remind a subscriber why this issue is worth their time |
| Length | 2–6 words | Whatever fits on a phone; front-load the topic |
| Tone | Plain, like an internal email | Your brand voice |
| Personalisation | Name, company or a real trigger (a hire, a page, a post) | Optional; topic matters more |
| Preview text | Your first sentence; make it specific | Write it on purpose; do not leave "View in browser" |
| Emoji, caps, ! | Avoid | Use sparingly |
The one large public dataset we could verify comes from Belkins. Its B2B cold email subject line study (published 6 Aug 2025, checked 7 Nov 2026) looked at more than 5.5 million emails sent in 2024. It reports that 2–4 word subject lines had the highest open rate (46%), and personalised lines opened at 46% against 35% without. These are one agency's results on its own campaigns, and open rates are a soft measure: Apple says its Mail Privacy Protection "makes it harder for senders to learn about your Mail activity". Treat them as direction, not a promise.
What we do before a send
4 checks we run that no tester can
A tester catches format problems. It cannot tell you whether the line is true, specific or right for this list. Before any campaign goes out, we read the subject and preview together, check the promise matches the body, send a test to a real phone, and keep one variable per A/B test.
- Read subject and preview as one sentence. In the inbox they sit side by side. If the preview repeats the subject, you wasted your second line.
- Check the promise. If the subject says "your pricing page", the first line must be about their pricing page. A mismatch gets the next email ignored, even when this one is opened.
- Test the fallback. Send one test with an empty first-name field. "Hi , quick question" is an easy mistake to ship and an obvious one to the reader.
- Judge cold email on replies, not opens. For outbound, the subject line's job is a reply-worthy open. Compare variants on reply rate and meetings booked, with at least a few hundred sends each.
Common questions
Email Subject Line Tester: FAQs
Related