Industries · Marketplaces

A marketplace marketing agency that grows both sides at once.

A marketplace only works when buyers find good options and sellers get real demand. SignalScaler is a marketplace marketing agency for B2B directories, review platforms and service marketplaces. We plan which side to grow first, make thousands of listing pages rank in search and AI answers, build reviews, and turn free listings into paid plans.

30 minutes. We tell you which side to grow first, even if you never hire us.

Our team built the growth system behind GoodFirms: 100K+ companies, 60,000+ reviews and 500K+ monthly organic visitors.

The short answer

What should a marketplace marketing agency actually do?

It should grow the marketplace, not just traffic. That means deciding which side to grow first, making listing and category pages rank, building reviews both sides trust, and turning participation into revenue. Each of these feeds the next, so they are planned as one system.

Most marketplace teams that call us have one side working and the other stuck. Plenty of free listings but few buyers, or buyers who arrive and find thin profiles. Ordinary agencies treat the platform like a single website and run campaigns for one audience. A marketplace needs two funnels, two messages and one plan that connects them.

Our view

How does marketing change by marketplace type?

The model decides what to measure. A directory lives on listings and buyer visits, a service marketplace on completed jobs, and a review platform on fresh, trusted reviews. Pick the one action that proves value on each side and build the plan around it.

Marketplace typeThe key actionWhat marketing should measureChannels we start with
B2B directories and review platformsA buyer contacts or shortlists a listed companyIndexed category pages, buyer visits per listing, reviews per month, paid upgradesListing-page SEO, AI search, review campaigns, email to listed companies
Service and freelancer marketplacesA job is posted and completedJobs posted, match rate, repeat buyers, seller retentionSearch ads on job intent, category SEO, outbound to supply, onboarding email
Software and product marketplacesA buyer compares and clicks through to a vendorComparison page traffic, vendor leads, sponsored placement revenueComparison content, structured data, vendor partnerships, newsletters
Staffing and talent platformsA client hires or books a personQualified client enquiries, fill rate, time to hire, active talentLinkedIn, outbound to hiring managers, referral programmes, talent SEO

What we see on first calls

Where does marketplace marketing usually stall?

Three gaps show up in most audits. Each one makes the other side harder to grow.

Growing the side that is already full
More seller sign-ups when buyers are the shortage, or more buyer traffic sent to empty categories. Both raise costs and lower trust.
Budget set by which side is short, category by category.
Thousands of thin listing pages
Profiles with a logo and two lines, near-identical location pages and no internal links. Search engines index a fraction and rank even less.
Listing templates and category structure built for search.
Free members with no reason to pay
Sellers never see how many buyers viewed them or what a paid plan would add. The upgrade email arrives once and is ignored.
Upgrade prompts built on each member's own numbers.

The first decision

Which side of a marketplace should you grow first?

Usually supply, in one narrow niche. Buyers return only when they find good options, so make one category, city or use case worth visiting before you spend on buyers. Then add the next niche. The order changes if supply is easy to get and buyers are scarce.

Not sure which side is holding you back?

Share your listings, buyer visits and paid conversions by category. We will show you which side is short and the first fix.

Get a free marketplace growth review →

Search and AI answers

How do marketplaces win search with thousands of listing pages?

Treat SEO as a design rule, not an add-on. Plan category and location structure before you scale, give each listing enough unique content to deserve a page, and connect everything with internal links. AI assistants lean on the same pages when they name vendors, so clear facts and real reviews help in both.

Want the detail? See our SEO, AEO and GEO service and the GoodFirms case study, where the platform reached 500K+ monthly organic visitors by 2021 and kept that level through 2025.

Trust

How do you build reviews and trust on both sides?

Make reviews part of the product journey. Ask at the moment of value, let listed companies invite their own clients, verify reviewers and show your moderation rules. Buyers trust a platform when reviews are recent, specific and clearly checked.

Revenue

How do marketplaces turn free listings into revenue?

Grow revenue with the platform, not against it. Most marketplaces combine two or three models. Each one needs its own marketing job, and none should make results worse for buyers, or buyers stop coming.

Revenue modelWorks best whenThe marketing job
Premium profiles and visibility plansMany sellers compete in the same categoriesShow free members their views and missed enquiries; make paid benefits visible on the listing
Leads or pay-per-enquiryBuyers send clear, qualified requestsLead quality checks and reporting sellers can trust
Commission on transactionsJobs or bookings happen on the platformKeep transactions on-platform with protection, payments and reviews
Sponsored placement and advertisingBuyer traffic is high and well segmentedClear labels, category targeting and a media kit built on real audience data

Pricing the plans is part of the work. It sits in our product marketing service.

The SignalScaler approach

How we work with marketplaces

We can support your in-house team or run marketing end to end. Either way, the plan covers these four parts, in this order.

01 · Diagnose
Which side is short, where
We read supply, demand and conversion by category to find where the marketplace already works and where it stalls.
Scorecard for each side
First niche to focus on
Tracking from visit to paid member
02 · Discover
Listings that rank
Category structure, listing templates, structured data and buyer content for Google and AI assistants.
Technical SEO audit at template level
Category and comparison pages
AI search visibility checks
03 · Participate
Both sides active
Outbound and onboarding for supply, search and ads for demand, and review requests that keep the platform fresh.
Seller acquisition and onboarding email
Buyer campaigns by niche
Review request automation
04 · Monetise
Revenue that lasts
Upgrade journeys, paid plan positioning and sponsored placement, reported against buyer trust.
Free-to-paid upgrade flows
Plan and pricing page review
Monthly revenue and liquidity report

Proof

GoodFirms: from zero to a global B2B marketplace

Our team worked across strategy, brand, platform, search, community and monetisation for GoodFirms, a B2B platform where buyers find and review software and IT service providers. SEO was built into the platform from day one, and both sides of the marketplace were grown together.

500K+
Monthly organic visitors by 2021, sustained through 2025
100K+
Companies built into the platform
60,000+
Reviews building marketplace trust
$300K
Peak monthly revenue, grown from $0

Read the GoodFirms case study. We are also growing an on-demand task platform for a US real estate group, where the job is turning inactive sign-ups into active users.

Is this right for you?

Which marketplaces we work best with

Good fit if you...

Run a B2B directory, review platform, service, software or talent marketplace
Have listings or members already and want both sides to grow
Can share listing, traffic and revenue data by category
Want one partner to own the plan, with or without an in-house team

Probably not yet if you...

Are still choosing what the marketplace will be; start with a few manual matches
Run a consumer retail marketplace selling physical goods
Want traffic numbers without tying them to listings, reviews or revenue

Want a dedicated person on your team instead of an agency? Hire a SEO specialist, content writer, SDR or marketing automation specialist, or see how hiring works.

Common questions

Marketplace marketing agency: FAQs

Which side of a marketplace should we grow first?
Usually supply, in one narrow niche. Buyers only come back if they find good options, so first make one category or one city worth visiting, then market to buyers there. If supply is easy to get but buyers are scarce, flip it. We decide from your data, not a rule.
How do marketplaces get thousands of listing pages indexed?
Plan the category and location structure before you scale, link listings from category pages, keep sitemaps clean, add structured data, and keep thin or empty pages out of the index until they have real content. At GoodFirms, SEO was a design rule from day one, not an add-on.
How do we get more reviews on our platform?
Ask at the moment of value: after a project ends, a booking completes or a renewal happens. Make it short, let the reviewed company invite its own clients, verify reviewers, and show that reviews are moderated. A steady flow beats a one-off campaign.
How do we get free listings to upgrade to paid plans?
Show free members what they are missing with their own numbers: profile views, buyer searches in their category and leads they could have received. Then make the paid plan's benefit visible on the public listing, such as a better position or a verified badge.
Do marketplaces still need SEO now that buyers ask AI assistants?
Yes. AI assistants often cite directory, comparison and review pages when they recommend vendors. The same things help in both: clear category pages, consistent facts, real reviews and structured data.
Can you work with our in-house team, or run all our marketing?
Both. Some platforms want us to plan and support their team; others want us to run growth end to end on both sides of the marketplace. We agree the scope after a first review.
Free marketplace growth review · no commitment

Grow the side that is holding you back.

Tell us your model, your categories and where members drop off. We will show you the first two fixes we would make and how we would measure them.

A 30-minute conversation. No obligation to work with us after.

We use cookies to understand how visitors use this site. Analytics cookies stay off unless you say yes — see our Cookie Policy for details.

Cookie Preferences

Strictly Necessary
Required for the site to function. Always on, cannot be disabled.
Analytics
Helps us understand how visitors use the site (Google Analytics). Off by default.